Name: New York Pizzeria
Address: 2 E Main St, Trumansburg, New York, 14886, US
Telephone: +1 607-387-3700
Price range: $10-20

Welcome to New York Pizzeria

Signature Dining Experience

New York Pizzeria opens its doors to a slice of authentic Italian goodness in Trumansburg. Located at 2 E Main St, this restaurant welcomes everyone with its delightful aroma of freshly baked pies. The moment you step inside, a friendly atmosphere wraps around you like a warm blanket. With its focus on New York-style pizza, the menu features countless options that cater to all cravings.

From classic cheese slices to savory specialty pies, diners find satisfaction in every bite. Price points remain friendly, allowing both families and local pizza enthusiasts to indulge without breaking the bank. Whether you enjoy dining in or grabbing a slice to go, this pizzeria thrives on creating a community hub where delicious food and good company come together.

Location & Contact

Address

2 E Main St, Trumansburg, NY 14886, United States

Phone

+1 607-387-3700

About

New York Pizzeria stands not just as a restaurant, but as a beloved fixture in the Trumansburg community. Opening its doors to serve the public, it focuses on providing the most authentic New York-style pizzas outside the Big Apple. The establishment balances high-quality, traditional recipes with the fresh tastes of local produce, bringing out the best in every ingredient. The menu is thoughtfully curated with ten popular dishes, ensuring customers have ample options to delight their taste buds. Among the favorites are the large pizzas, perfect for sharing with family or friends.

The pizzeria caters to a diverse clientele, including families, college students, and local pizza aficionados. Its accessibility makes it a convenient choice for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner. One unique aspect of New York Pizzeria is the bustling atmosphere that peaks on busy nights. Wednesdays around 6 PM showcase the restaurant at 100% capacity, reflecting its popularity among locals. However, diners can find quieter times, especially on Tuesday evenings or Thursday early afternoons, to enjoy a slice with less hustle and bustle.

The pizzeria's commitment to service excellence deepens community ties, as it frequently hosts events and participates in local festivals. Through its dedication to quality pizza and community spirit, New York Pizzeria has turned meal times into cherished gatherings and builds lasting memories for all who visit.

Work Hours

SundayClosed
MondayClosed
Tuesday12-8 PM
Wednesday12-8 PM
Thursday12-8 PM
Friday12-8 PM
Saturday12-8 PM

New York Pizzeria prides itself on offering a host of mouthwatering features. The signature NY-style pizzas here are the main attraction, characterized by their thin crust and generous toppings, reflecting the essence of New York's street food culture. Each meal promises a delightful experience with quality ingredients tailored to local tastes. Customers rave about the Cheese Slice with Sausage and the White Pizza with Tomato, highlighting them as must-tries. Additionally, for those who love choices, New York Pizzeria specializes in pizza by the slice, perfect for lunch breaks or an afternoon snack.

The laid-back vibe coupled with an impressive selection of sodas, including local favorite White Birch Soda, completes the dining experience. A casual ambiance makes it an ideal spot for families, friends, and visitors alike to gather and enjoy a true taste of pizza perfection. “

With the restaurant located near beautiful local scenery and a vibrant brewery, customers can grab a slice then savor a nearby craft beer, enhancing their experience.

The exterior of New York Pizzeria boasts an inviting façade that beckons pizza lovers from afar. A vibrant sign and warm lighting illuminate the entrance, creating a familiar, welcoming vibe for both new and returning visitors. The outdoor seating options provide a relaxed place to enjoy pizza al fresco, particularly enjoyable during the warmer months. Feel free to grab a slice and unwind while taking in the lively street scene of Trumansburg. This casual outdoor setting fosters a friendly atmosphere, perfect for socializing or simply unwinding after a long day.

Nestled close to beautiful lakes and local breweries, the location offers a scenic backdrop that enhances the dining experience. If you want a taste of tradition with a splash of community, you’ll find it right here.

Customer Reviews

They had at least 8 or 9 different types of pizza available by the slice (including some unique combinations) on a Saturday afternoon when we stopped in. There are a few tables to sit inside. Service was quick and friendly.

Thor Y.

We stopped in here for lunch. We were happy that they sell pizza by the slice. We got pepperoni pizza. It was hot and tasty. Service was fast and friendly. I would stop here again.

Christine G.

Great pizzeria with fun sodas. Sicilian it maybe NYC style. Crispy and chewy. Great crust. lots of choices by the slice at about 2 PM. Loved it

Mike

Great Pizza spot in the area. The pizza itself was thin-crusted and really good, with nice different ingredient options. Very impressed & pleasantly surprised with the veg pizza slice options they had.

yash m.

A nice visit in a small town. Right up the road from Taughannock Falls and worth the short trip. Cool sodas and lemonades in the cooler. Extra large cheese (pictured) was $18 today. We ate in and it was a very pleasant experience. Lots of slice options readily available if that's what you're looking for. Thanks for having us.

Marshall B.

While visiting Garrett's Brewing next door, we ordered pizza from New York Pizzeria. The service was excellent and the pie was DELICIOUS!! Although busy, it was totally worth the wait to taste authentic NYC pizza. Highly recommended!!

Jon A.

New York Pizzeria